Bandit Alley

GENERAL MOTORCYCLE FORUMS => GENERAL MECHANICAL & TECHNICAL => Topic started by: DaveG on February 19, 2009, 12:59:10 PM

Title: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: DaveG on February 19, 2009, 12:59:10 PM
almost hate to start another oil filter thread but i see that the pure one is now made in china.

it was my filter of choice but it doesn't look so good anymore.

thinking K&N but that's alot to pay for a nut.
HiFlo may be my next choice

so chime in;

who likes what lately


BTW I use Rotella synth. 5w40
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: PaulVS on February 19, 2009, 01:08:29 PM
Since the STP SM0-18 is no longer available anywhere near me... I use the Suzuki OEM.  It's the best rated of the ones made for the Bandit, and you can occassionally find deals on them.

I recently picked up 4 of them for about $32 shipped.

Other than that... most people seem to find the WIX/NAPA filter to be the best bang-for-the-buck.


EDIT:  The Hi-Flo looks to do pretty well in this comparison...

http://www.calsci.com/motorcycleinfo/FilterStudy.html
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: txbanditrydr on February 19, 2009, 02:44:42 PM
who likes what lately
Quote
I use the Suzuki OEM.  It's the best rated of the ones made for the Bandit

+1..... every other oil change (4,000 miles max)

Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: B6mick on February 19, 2009, 05:31:08 PM
Actually I'm turning away from the lot of them, and saving the bucks for a new reusable unit that is fully servicable. about $200 Aus.

Standard filters are rated to 10 micron, these suckers are rated to 30 micron +.

No brainer there. In 50 thousand K's its paid for itself, and the extra 20 microns of protection is free.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: pmackie on February 20, 2009, 01:49:48 AM
Hey Mick

Quote
Standard filters are rated to 10 micron, these suckers are rated to 30 micron +.

Filters are normally rated based on the maximum size particle they will let past. You can get either "Absolute" or "Nominal". An Absolute will not let ANY particles of the listed size or larger through, whereas Nominal lists the average particle size. I haven't ever looked at the specs on our oil filters, so I don't know what they are.

Anyway, my point here is that the unit you are considering will let a 30 micron particle past, where the stock one will only let a 10 micron particle past. (assuming you listed the data accurately) 30 microns is a LOT larger...
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: B6mick on February 20, 2009, 08:37:28 PM
opps. :banghead:

Correction required.
I got the figures the wrong way round. :duh:

My tyre supplier who is a total efen nutter, hope he don't mind me calling him that, Paul from Cyco engineering, turned on to them, he preps all sorts of racing engines.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Vlad on February 21, 2009, 12:06:14 PM
My tyre supplier who is a total efen nutter, hope he don't mind me calling him that, Paul from Cyco engineering, turned on to them, he preps all sorts of racing engines.

Are you talking about one of these?

http://www.suzukisv1000.com/products/v3_oil_filters.htm

http://www.gopurepower.com/store/item.asp?itemID=8400&dia=true

A quick calculation tells me that it would take somewhere between 100,000Km and 200,000Km for one of those to pay for them self, and that's if I don't take into account the time/effort spent to clean them. In absence of independent test results, I don't believe a washable stainless steel mesh can filter any better than standard paper filter and I also don't believe it can be washed thoroughly and/or easily enough. Also, for that kind of money they should have included a nut on top of it :). Just my 2c.

I used K&N, but have recently switched mostly to OEM. Change them sometimes every oil change, sometimes every other, depending on how long I've run the oil and which oil I've used.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: B6mick on February 21, 2009, 10:36:51 PM
My tyre supplier who is a total efen nutter, hope he don't mind me calling him that, Paul from Cyco engineering, turned on to them, he preps all sorts of racing engines.

Are you talking about one of these?

http://www.suzukisv1000.com/products/v3_oil_filters.htm

http://www.gopurepower.com/store/item.asp?itemID=8400&dia=true

A quick calculation tells me that it would take somewhere between 100,000Km and 200,000Km for one of those to pay for them self, and that's if I don't take into account the time/effort spent to clean them. In absence of independent test results, I don't believe a washable stainless steel mesh can filter any better than standard paper filter and I also don't believe it can be washed thoroughly and/or easily enough. Also, for that kind of money they should have included a nut on top of it :). Just my 2c.

I used K&N, but have recently switched mostly to OEM. Change them sometimes every oil change, sometimes every other, depending on how long I've run the oil and which oil I've used.


No 50 thousand K's mate.

Change oil every 5 thou. the price of the Oil filter against the price of throw away unit, yes I'm a bit anal maybe But I toss the filter everytime I change the oil. So I don't know what you pay for a K&N
We downunder pay at trade near $20 for the 138c (nice chrome one.)

If you don't believe they are any better,( the washable unit ) thats fine, but if race teams here are turning to them, and sponcership money is not a problem, one has to ask why? and I did, they are convinced of the 20 micron protection benifit.

Yes they are very similar, not the same units I'm looking at.
also differnt in the filtering surfaces, as the one I'm looking at has a multi layered discs that act as the filtering surfaces, a total breeze to clean, when I get my hands on one I'll pull it all apart and send pics
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Blade on February 22, 2009, 12:52:25 AM
Another thing to consider with the lower micron rating is that it will also affect oil flow. So it could change oil delivery to your engine. Bandit air/oil cooled already have a slight issues with oil delivery to the top end.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Vlad on February 22, 2009, 01:07:59 AM
No 50 thousand K's mate.

I based my calculation on $10 (Canadian) per paper filter (that's what I pay for OEM if I buy 4 or more) and approximately $200 (again Canadian) for the "washable" unit (rough average of US$120-200 for those I've seen on the web).

If you don't believe they are any better,( the washable unit ) thats fine, but if race teams here are turning to them, and sponcership money is not a problem, one has to ask why? and I did, they are convinced of the 20 micron protection benifit.

I don't believe until it's substantiated by hard facts. Race teams are not a very good reference, IMO, as they overhaul their engines much more often than I plan on doing. They are probably more interested in the unrestricted flow of oil than filtering properties. I also dismiss manufacturer's claims as inflated by default until/unless they are proven by independent testing. If they don't list the lab results they can claim whatever they want - I don't see a 30 micron hole any better than a 10 micron one :). 

Yes they are very similar, not the same units I'm looking at.
also differnt in the filtering surfaces, as the one I'm looking at has a multi layered discs that act as the filtering surfaces, a total breeze to clean, when I get my hands on one I'll pull it all apart and send pics

I'm looking forward to hear your first hand impressions and see the pictures. Contrary to what it may seem, I'm quite open to the idea of not having to buy/throw away a filter every month. I'm just skeptic because I've seen too much snake oil before.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Red01 on February 22, 2009, 03:50:56 PM
I've dealt with those re-useable type stainless mesh filters before in aircraft and I hated having to clean them.  In the aircraft biz, we had to use special solvents and an ultrasonic cleaning machine.  Due to the time and expense involved in cleaning filter elements, the industry has pretty much gone to disposable elements that fit in the same bowl as the old cleanable ones.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: PaulVS on February 22, 2009, 04:05:16 PM
I'd tend to stick with the paper filter type myself... about 5 years worth of them to pay for the s/s mesh filter. 

Cleaning a filter every oil change?  Meh.  Don't have the time. 

Mainly though, I've never heard of anyone who had anything near an engine failure that resulted from using the OEM filter.

And also... I think a Murphy's Law Addendum states that the minute you spend $100 on an oil filter is the same time you will wad your bike and not be able to use said filter ever again.   :grin:
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: B6mick on March 07, 2009, 04:11:15 AM
Another thing to consider with the lower micron rating is that it will also affect oil flow. So it could change oil delivery to your engine. Bandit air/oil cooled already have a slight issues with oil delivery to the top end.
They are in fact a lot larger than the standard spin on unit, hench they don't have a problem of starving the engine of oil, but they do have a problem that has stopped me in my tracks. One would have to remove the headers to remove and install this filter, so thats a big PITA, as as much as I love wrenching on my bikes, that is the end of my idea of buying such a unit. :sad:
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: DaveG on March 09, 2009, 05:16:52 PM
i went with the OEM    $10.95 vs. 6.95 for the Purolator
what the heck $4 and it seems to be a very good filter.


Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: gyrogearcrunch on April 10, 2009, 11:36:49 PM
My tyre supplier who is a total efen nutter, hope he don't mind me calling him that, Paul from Cyco engineering, turned on to them, he preps all sorts of racing engines.

Are you talking about one of these?

http://www.suzukisv1000.com/products/v3_oil_filters.htm

http://www.gopurepower.com/store/item.asp?itemID=8400&dia=true

A quick calculation tells me that it would take somewhere between 100,000Km and 200,000Km for one of those to pay for them self, and that's if I don't take into account the time/effort spent to clean them. In absence of independent test results, I don't believe a washable stainless steel mesh can filter any better than standard paper filter and I also don't believe it can be washed thoroughly and/or easily enough. Also, for that kind of money they should have included a nut on top of it :). Just my 2c.

I used K&N, but have recently switched mostly to OEM. Change them sometimes every oil change, sometimes every other, depending on how long I've run the oil and which oil I've used.

Try to find a smaller "toilet-paper oil filter" kit, a remote cap to fit your bike, and install it. You will be amazed and stupefied at the wonders that follow. You think diesel engines are long-lived? You think a spin-on filter will increase your gas mileage by at least 10%? Fuggedaboudit! I speak from personal experience with one of these filters from J.C. Whitney back in 1972 ($17.95!!!) on my car for over 100,000 miles. The only reason I had to change oil at all was to freshen up the oil additive package.

There are just one or two T.P. oil filter makers left out there, far as I know, and they are mainly used on diesels. They sure as dickens don't go for $18 bucks anymore either.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: mademiriam on April 11, 2009, 10:09:45 AM
ah nothing like the smell of a oil filter thread in the morning.  :grin:
I'm using OEM or FRAM, the fram because it is usually about half the price.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Red01 on April 21, 2009, 11:29:55 AM
ah nothing like the smell of a oil filter thread in the morning.  :grin:
I'm using OEM or FRAM, the fram because it is usually about half the price.

 :yikes: She said the "F" word!  :duh:
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: PaulVS on April 21, 2009, 12:10:51 PM
ah nothing like the smell of a oil filter thread in the morning.  :grin:
I'm using OEM or FRAM, the fram because it is usually about half the price.

 :yikes: She said the "F" word!  :duh:

+1.  While Fram makes some very good oil filters... It seems their offering for the Bandit is probably the worst option out there...  based on some professional analysis.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: mademiriam on April 21, 2009, 02:37:52 PM
 I've actually tried to find the info and can't maybe google fails me.  :stickpoke: If you're wondering why canadians seem to be using FRAM a lot it's because canadian tire (a big autoparts etc. store) sells them, at the suzuki dealer a filter was $20 last time I checked  :yikes:. Maybe the price is more reasonable now or I could get a male to ask for me as that always gets better results.  :motorsmile: Thats right go ahead and laugh I have a heck of a time getting decent service at a motorcycle store.
Both of our bikes use the same filters, so I usually buy four or so at a time.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: PaulVS on April 21, 2009, 03:39:12 PM
I've actually tried to find the info and can't maybe google fails me.

Here's one...

http://www.calsci.com/motorcycleinfo/FilterStudy.html

You can see the Fram filter gets "F" and "C" grades on its construction.

Others have done some dissecting comparisons as well and found it wanting.

The Wix & NAPA filters are good alternatives to the OEM.  Also, the STP filter may still be available in Canada.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: gyrogearcrunch on April 27, 2009, 10:00:20 PM
almost hate to start another oil filter thread but i see that the pure one is now made in china.

it was my filter of choice but it doesn't look so good anymore.

thinking K&N but that's alot to pay for a nut.
HiFlo may be my next choice

so chime in;

who likes what lately

BTW I use Rotella synth. 5w40

Great oil. Diesel truckers use it a lot. The other great diesel oil is Mobil Delvac 1300 Super, 15W-40. Supposed to have the best additive package out there, but it isn't synthetic, so it's very cheap. I find it in Walmarts everywhere. Been using Delvac in my '99 Bandit 1200 until just recently, when I switched to Royal Purple synthetic. The Purple stuff costs more per quart than what the Mobil Delvac costs for a gallon., but the 1200 seems to like the purple stuff better. Hm-mmm! Live and learn!
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: snofrog on June 07, 2009, 07:21:18 PM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: gyrogearcrunch on June 08, 2009, 05:07:48 PM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .

Go here. Fast Larry has compiled no end of useful data on oil & mods in a manual, including links to "how to" stuff like reworking the 1200 Bandit's crappy front suspension: http://www.portablepct.com/fastlarry/banditfaq.htm#general_info
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: snofrog on June 08, 2009, 08:19:01 PM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .

Go here. Fast Larry has compiled no end of useful data on oil & mods in a manual, including links to "how to" stuff like reworking the 1200 Bandit's crappy front suspension: http://www.portablepct.com/fastlarry/banditfaq.htm#general_info

uhhhhh NO !  :beers:

btw last time I went to his site witch has been a couple years ago my A/V sounded like a tornado siren
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: gyrogearcrunch on June 08, 2009, 08:26:32 PM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .

Go here. Fast Larry has compiled no end of useful data on oil & mods in a manual, including links to "how to" stuff like reworking the 1200 Bandit's crappy front suspension: http://www.portablepct.com/fastlarry/banditfaq.htm#general_info

uhhhhh NO !  :beers:

--->Try the link. I experienced no noise at all, and my speakers were on just an hour ago when I tried the site. Really!  :thumb:

Fast Larry apparently likes Suzuki OEM filters, but I have never tried Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil - don't even know where to get it.  :banghead: <---

btw last time I went to his site witch has been a couple years ago my A/V sounded like a tornado siren
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: snofrog on June 08, 2009, 10:38:27 PM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .

Go here. Fast Larry has compiled no end of useful data on oil & mods in a manual, including links to "how to" stuff like reworking the 1200 Bandit's crappy front suspension: http://www.portablepct.com/fastlarry/banditfaq.htm#general_info

uhhhhh NO !  :beers:

--->Try the link. I experienced no noise at all, and my speakers were on just an hour ago when I tried the site. Really!  :thumb:

Fast Larry apparently likes Suzuki OEM filters, but I have never tried Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil - don't even know where to get it.  :banghead: <---

btw last time I went to his site witch has been a couple years ago my A/V sounded like a tornado siren

http://klotzlube.com/storeProdDetails.asp?pi=64
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: gyrogearcrunch on June 10, 2009, 03:39:52 AM
I use suzuki filters and Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil.right or wrong thats what I use .

Go here. Fast Larry has compiled no end of useful data on oil & mods in a manual, including links to "how to" stuff like reworking the 1200 Bandit's crappy front suspension: http://www.portablepct.com/fastlarry/banditfaq.htm#general_info

Thank you, Snofrog! Went to Klotz website and bokkmarked it.
uhhhhh NO !  :beers:

--->Try the link. I experienced no noise at all, and my speakers were on just an hour ago when I tried the site. Really!  :thumb:

Fast Larry apparently likes Suzuki OEM filters, but I have never tried Klotz 10-40 techniplate oil - don't even know where to get it.  :banghead: <---

btw last time I went to his site witch has been a couple years ago my A/V sounded like a tornado siren

http://klotzlube.com/storeProdDetails.asp?pi=64
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: Dave 02 1200 on October 31, 2009, 03:00:29 PM
I imagine that one reason why race teams use the stainless mesh reusable filters is that they are frequently reassembling their motors using moly-paste assembly lube to protect cams and bearings on start-up.

That stuff quickly plugs paper elements so oil can no longer flow through the paper element.

When the elements get plugged, the by-pass valve opens allowing unfiltered oil to pass.

All that is avoided with a stainless mesh type filter.

But for normal oil change duty, I think the paper element OEM filter is best.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: smooth operator on November 02, 2009, 07:53:03 PM
  That ss reusable sure would look good on my SV. Chage it about every 3 track days or 1000 to 1500 miles. I had my pal quit bringing in the Fram filters for the Bandit, I've been using the K&N on the Bandit and OEM on the SV.
Title: Re: LATEST ON OIL FILTERS
Post by: stormi on November 03, 2009, 01:01:38 AM
ah nothing like the smell of a oil filter thread in the morning.  :grin:
I'm using OEM or FRAM, the fram because it is usually about half the price.

 :yikes: She said the "F" word!  :duh:

We haven't touched fram since the 919 got low-sided in the grass, and the filter collapsed, throwing a low oil pressure light.

http://forums.banditalley.net/index.php?topic=5990.0

I've actually tried to find the info and can't maybe google fails me.

Here's one...

http://www.calsci.com/motorcycleinfo/FilterStudy.html

You can see the Fram filter gets "F" and "C" grades on its construction.

Others have done some dissecting comparisons as well and found it wanting.

The Wix & NAPA filters are good alternatives to the OEM.  Also, the STP filter may still be available in Canada.

We use the Napa ones,... they can survive a small crash, unlike the Fram ones. 

I -really- have to stop rating my oil filters on their crash survivability.   :duh:

Additionally, this page, has saved me a small fortune:
http://www.calsci.com/motorcycleinfo/FilterXRef.html