Bandit Alley

GENERAL MOTORCYCLE FORUMS => GENERAL MECHANICAL & TECHNICAL => Topic started by: H2RICK on November 10, 2006, 02:26:59 PM

Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on November 10, 2006, 02:26:59 PM
pulling the sealing strip plug thingy from the top of his/her "sealed" battery and checking/adding distilled water to any low cells ??
I've never had a bike with this new style battery in it and was just wondering what the protocol is on maintenance. These things HAVE to use up the acid/water fluid.....don't they ??
Or do you just ride until it dies ??
What's YOUR experience ???
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: zeebandit on November 10, 2006, 03:37:57 PM
I would'nt pull the sealing strip. I think that would guarantee you're going to have evaporation or overflow. If you do add fluid it should be water, never acid. :stop:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Sven on November 10, 2006, 10:22:14 PM
I voted for A/R!  They call it a "sealed battery" because you leave it alone until it quits working, when you get a new one!  Be happy technology has advanced that far and polish the bike...or go riding!
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: 00to60 on November 11, 2006, 02:17:57 AM
Just bought a new battery 3 weeks ago, because the other was 4 years old. It ran down one night when I left the headlight on for 30 minutes.


 :motorsmile:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: stormi on November 11, 2006, 04:23:24 AM
actually, I'm not sure that they do use a water/acid solution.  If you look up your battery model, it will usually mention that it's a "gel" battery.  I think that's partly so it doesn't spill, since they're often not fully upright.   Think cornering,...

In fact: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gel_battery
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: smooth operator on November 11, 2006, 06:35:03 AM
I still have the original battery, Mines a 98. Start it every few weels through the winter,and use a tender when not riding.  I Don't pull the strip on a sealed battery.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Sven on November 11, 2006, 11:49:28 AM
Quote
actually, I'm not sure that they do use a water/acid solution.  If you look up your battery model, it will usually mention that it's a "gel" battery.  I think that's partly so it doesn't spill, since they're often not fully upright.   Think cornering,...

In fact: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gel_battery


That was interesting.  I spend way too much time cruising Wikipedia...alwasy amazed at the breadth of what they have.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Desolation Angel on November 11, 2006, 07:39:18 PM
Quote from: "Sven"
Quote
actually, I'm not sure that they do use a water/acid solution.  If you look up your battery model, it will usually mention that it's a "gel" battery.  I think that's partly so it doesn't spill, since they're often not fully upright.   Think cornering,...

In fact: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gel_battery


That was interesting.  I spend way too much time cruising Wikipedia...always amazed at the breadth of what they have.


Yeah, an entry for every Playmate ever.  :bigok:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: CWO4GUNNER on November 11, 2006, 10:16:47 PM
Thank goodness they came out with these maintenance free batteries and it was way overdue as I remember the older acid batteries had to be replaced almost every year especially in personal watercraft that used the same stupid acid battery, which they wouldn’t accept as a core because they were disposable so you just tossed them over the boat or over the fence. Now I have a gel battery in all my toys and they have worked fine so far as long as I ride them at least once a week. Like any car battery I think now they have to accept the core when you buy a new one.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on November 13, 2006, 11:23:06 PM
Quote
it will usually mention that it's a "gel" battery


Nope, the battery that came in my B12SK6 came with an acid pack which I dumped in and then charged the battery while I assembled the bike. After the charging was complete I smacked the cap strip into place and went from there. Gel batteries are a totally different setup and ARE completely sealed....no strips/caps at all. Gel batteries are great for vehicles that regularly get upset (quads, watercraft, dirt bikes, etc) but hopefully that's not going to happen to #17....at least while I own her..... :grin:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: wheeliekev on November 14, 2006, 10:25:08 AM
i always connect the optimate up to my battery even when new  :grin:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: stormi on November 14, 2006, 03:11:34 PM
Quote


Nope, the battery that came in my B12SK6 came with an acid pack which I dumped in and then charged the battery while I assembled the bike. After the charging was complete I smacked the cap strip into place and went from there. Gel batteries are a totally different setup and ARE completely sealed....no strips/caps at all. Gel batteries are great for vehicles that regularly get upset (quads, watercraft, dirt bikes, etc) but hopefully that's not going to happen to #17....at least while I own her..... :grin:


Like this?

(http://www.mdsbattery.co.uk/images/products/Fullsize/YTX12BS.jpg)

From Wikipedia:
Quote
A gel battery is a rechargeable valve regulated lead-acid battery with a gelified electrolyte. Unlike a traditional wet-cell lead-acid battery, these batteries do not need to be kept upright (though they cannot be charged inverted). In addition, gel batteries virtually eliminate the electrolyte evaporation, spillage (and subsequent corrosion issues) common to the wet-cell battery, and boast greater resistance to extreme temperatures, shock, and vibration. As a result, they are primarily used in automobiles, boats, aircraft, and other motorized vehicles. These batteries are often colloquially referred to as sealed lead-acid (SLA) batteries due to their non-leaking containers, but they are not completely sealed; the valve regulation system allows for gas to be expelled. Chemically they are the same as wet (non sealed) batteries except that the antimony in the lead plates is replaced by calcium.


That would make your battery a gel battery.  Did you have to add water?  Will you have to check the levels on it? When I look up the 2005 GSF1200 battery, it is a gel based battery, is yours different?  What's the model #? The one I see is a YTX12-BS....

Here, Edmonton, when you buy a gel filled battery from the dealer, generally, they put the acid gel in for you, and put the strip on it.  Then more often than not, they charge it for you, before you come to pick it up.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on November 15, 2006, 12:02:16 PM
Yep, that Varta is exactly the same setup.....but the pack contains sulphuric acid as a liquid, not a gel. I'll have to take a pic of a REAL gel-cell by Yuasa that we have at work so you can see the difference. They can be mounted/operated/charged in ANY orientation. It's interesting that even Wikipedia seems confused about the differences between what a true gel-cell is and what a lead-acid battery is.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: stormi on November 15, 2006, 02:50:15 PM
Quote from: "H2RICK"
Yep, that Varta is exactly the same setup.....but the pack contains sulphuric acid as a liquid, not a gel. I'll have to take a pic of a REAL gel-cell by Yuasa that we have at work so you can see the difference. They can be mounted/operated/charged in ANY orientation. It's interesting that even Wikipedia seems confused about the differences between what a true gel-cell is and what a lead-acid battery is.


I think it might be a "misnomer" (sp?)

It's likely almost right in between acid and gel, design-wise.  The reason I say that is that a lot of websites you look that battery up on has it under "gel" batteries.  It's mostly I think because the stuff you put in is thicker than water.  Not a "true" gel battery, but more a reference to the stuff you put in.  I bet if the batteries were never supplied with the bottle ( pre-activated) that they wouldn 't have gotten the "wrong" name.

However, that said it IS still a "maintenance free" battery, which means that the OP's question of opening it and adding water would not really be "necessary" and I wonder how it would mix with that stuff from the bottle.

Wikipedia is only as good as the people putting the information in.  A wiki allows anyone to submit information to it.  However, there was a point in that article where they did mention that there were suggestions of merging that one into the lead acid definition.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on November 16, 2006, 07:56:57 PM
Quote
I think it might be a "misnomer" (sp?)

It certainly is !!! That's the result of ignorance or greed on the part of the advertiser/seller of the sealed lead/acid battery....
usually a no-neck mouth breather at your local big-box dealership who wouldn't know a gel-cell if it fell on his head.....
but he heard that "gel-cell is the way to go" and so ALL batteries have suddenly become "gel-cells" to him. That way he gets more commissions selling "gel-cells" to people as ignorant as he is. Grrrr......



Quote
stuff you put in is thicker than water.

Nawww....it's just good old battery-grade sulphuric acid that's been around since the invention of the wet lead/acid battery. Nothing fancy.....unless it somehow "gels" when it gets put into the battery...but I doubt that. I think I'll pry my cap strip off and take a look just to satisfy my curiousity.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: stormi on November 16, 2006, 08:24:32 PM
Quote

It certainly is !!! That's the result of ignorance or greed on the part of the advertiser/seller of the sealed lead/acid battery....
usually a no-neck mouth breather at your local big-box dealership who wouldn't know a gel-cell if it fell on his head.....
but he heard that "gel-cell is the way to go" and so ALL batteries have suddenly become "gel-cells" to him. That way he gets more commissions selling "gel-cells" to people as ignorant as he is. Grrrr......


Yeah, but how do you really feel? :stickpoke:



Quote
Nawww....it's just good old battery-grade sulphuric acid that's been around since the invention of the wet lead/acid battery. Nothing fancy.....unless it somehow "gels" when it gets put into the battery...but I doubt that. I think I'll pry my cap strip off and take a look just to satisfy my curiousity.


Well isn't that strange?  The guy that sold me the battery specifically mentioned that it was a gel that was put in the battery.  Perhaps he didn't really know.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on November 19, 2006, 02:57:11 PM
Quote
Yeah, but how do you really feel? stickpoke

Stormi, when you get to be my age, you call a spade a spade.
I am NOT/NOT/NOT politically correct when it comes to bikes, or much else for that matter, as you may guess from my signature at the bottom of my posts. :wink: :grin:

Quote
Perhaps he didn't really know.

I'm willing to bet he wouldn't have the faintest idea what a true gel-cell looks like or works like.....and the scarey part is that he's an "expert" hired by that dealer for customers to depend on for info, opinions and "facts". :shock:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: stormi on November 20, 2006, 06:31:54 PM
Quote from: "H2RICK"

Stormi, when you get to be my age, you call a spade a spade.
I am NOT/NOT/NOT politically correct when it comes to bikes, or much else for that matter, as you may guess from my signature at the bottom of my posts. :wink: :grin:

LOL!  Perhaps I'm a little ahead of my time then.  I can really be guilty of the same,  

Quote
I'm willing to bet he wouldn't have the faintest idea what a true gel-cell looks like or works like.....and the scarey part is that he's an "expert" hired by that dealer for customers to depend on for info, opinions and "facts". :shock:


There's a reason that I always do my research before I bother to go into the dealer.  I didn't really think that researching a battery at the time was important,... guess I was wrong.  :grin:   That said, I'm buying less and less from the dealers here.  It's turning out to be a lot cheaper to import from the states.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: 350ers on December 04, 2006, 11:11:25 PM
You guys are making me nervous with all this battery talk..I still have the original in my '97 ( 38K ) My Interceptor went 11 years before I changed the battery and I did it just because I didn't want to be suprised one morning and have to drive a cage to work. Neither battery gave me a hint of trouble..both were/are maint. free oem Yuasa.
I probably just put a hex on myself for even mentioning this.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: H2RICK on December 08, 2006, 02:15:27 PM
350ers:
That's the kind of info I like to hear....actual user input.
With that kind of battery life, I've gotta assume you take care of your batteries properly, don't let the posts get corroded, etc etc. Of course where you live makes a difference as to battery life as well: temperate climates are best....too hot or too cool and the battery suffers....usually. Bad road surfaces (like we have in lotsa places in the Great White North) can wreck a battery really quick, even on modern bikes.
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Daytona on December 16, 2006, 10:10:48 AM
Maint free battery! None vent lead acid but has fibre in the cells to keep from slosh etc. Gell cell complete sealed in gell, can be positioned up, down, etc. Won't hold up in hot climate area's and is very expensive. Sealed M/C battery of good quality power max is a good choice. The B12 Needs a good battery to crank that eng, don't wear out the alt making it charge all the time, and non vent good sealed one will not turn under your seat into crap like that walmart one will. All over the web.
  Suzuki GSF1200S Bandit Motorcycle Battery (1997-2003)   $50.75
  The Suzuki GSF1200S Bandit Motorcycle Battery (1997-2003) cross-references to the following: Power Max GTX12-BS ... 9375Width3.4375Height5.125Warranty1 YearChemistrySLASealed AGM battery. Rugged maintenance-free design. Shipped pre-charged and ready to ...
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Daytona on December 16, 2006, 10:17:20 AM
Don't be a idiot and milk that crap battery that will leave you in the parkin lot, burn out your charging and your ignition sys that ain't cheap to fix, all for a 60$ battery! Your trusty steed deserves better. :motorsmile:  :beers:  :bigok:
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: smooth operator on December 16, 2006, 10:54:39 AM
Quote from: "Daytona"
Don't be a idiot and milk that crap battery that will leave you in the parkin lot, burn out your charging and your ignition sys that ain't cheap to fix, all for a 60$ battery! Your trusty steed deserves better. :motorsmile:  :beers:  :bigok:

   I'll 2nd the motion
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Daytona on December 16, 2006, 11:09:24 AM
Quote
="smooth operator"]
Quote from: "Daytona"
Don't be a idiot and milk that crap battery that will leave you in the parkin lot, burn out your charging and your ignition sys that ain't cheap to fix, all for a 60$ battery! Your trusty steed deserves better. :motorsmile:  :beers:  :bigok:
  I'll 2nd the motion
Hey you tile settin draggon slayin fool! Hope your enjoyin the winter up there Geeezzz! What do ya think of my riggins on the Busa? if you and the Mrs's are in the area yoawl have an invite here! if its during speed weeks bike stuff the first of march i can get tickets!

(http://shutter10.pictures.aol.com/data/pictures/09/007/7F/6D/CD/56/1my8MZWUmv-9jaRPsK39mXrfpcRGWtxa0300.jpg)
Title: OK, Who Will Admit To...
Post by: Daytona on December 16, 2006, 11:25:42 AM
Sorry for hijackin the post! So many will milk a battery like its the last one to be had. I'm like that with tires! Dumb i know! It to will teach me like the crap battery did! My lawn mower I had to jump start one time, while mowing, smoked the coil under the flywheel milkin it! Dumb!
A new battery from wally world was 20, the fix at the shop could have paid the lawn cutters for a year!
:duh:  :shock: