So I did a compression test (cold engine) and here are the results:
Cylinder 1: 100 psi dry, @ 12.82v (key in off position); 210 psi w/ ~5 ml of oil added into cyl, 12.66v;
Cylinder 2: 45 psi dry, 12.77v; 180 psi wet, 12.60v;
Cylinder 3: 50 psi dry, 12.72v; 170 psi wet, 12.52v;
Cylinder 4: 85 psi dry, 12.69v; 150 psi wet, 12.46v;
I'm kinda doubting the shop that did the compression test actually did the oil in cylinders check to differentiate between bad rings vs bad valves. (in hindsight, they didn't voluntarily say that they did the compression test wet as well, they just said yes, when I asked if they did it)
other notes:
at 23788 mi, I drained only 1300 ml of oil from engine (cold), then filled up w/ 2300 ml.
at 26226 mi, again, I drained only 1300 ml from engine (this time warm), then filled up w/ 2300 ml.
I found it odd that the engine only had 1300 ml both times that I drained the oil. (I did not keep record of the mileage of the oil change preceding the 23788 oil change.) Maybe there is a maximum burn threshold for the engine?? Assuming the oil consumption is linear, my burn rate was 390 ml per 1000 mi. From 26226 mi to engine death, I made an effort to add 200 ml per 500 miles, but in actuality ended up adding in increments of 150 or 300 ml (always correlating with mileage, I just wasn't always in a good place to stop at the 500 mi increments). At 23788 miles, I shoved off from Philadelphia. I made it up to Vancouver, BC, then down to LA and the shit hit the fan while riding out to Vegas. The engine was quite loaded at times: me, all my luggage + the Continental Divide, other climbs to 8000 ft etc...
I did a compression test (warm engine) 3 mos before the trip and these were the results:
cyl 1: 145 psi dry @ 12.69v; 215 psi wet 12.60v;
cyl 2: 155 psi dry @ 12.73v; 260* psi wet 12.71v;
cyl 3: 150 psi dry @ 12.83v; 205 psi wet 12.84v;
cyl 4: 160 psi dry @ 12.82v; 205 psi wet 12.80v;
*i think the oil, ~5 ml, went into cyl 2 most effectively "nothing but net". Oil was added via syringe, but the syringe was too wide to fit down into the spark plug hole, and i didn't have a hose small enough to plumb it directly into each cylinder, so I just aimed and squirted. In the other cylinders, the oil went into the plug hole, but also pooled in the general cavity. Cylinder 2 went straight in the hole. (with this latest C-test, I used a hose to pipe the oil directly into each cylinder.)
also to note, I do have a spare engine already, I'd just like to learn what went wrong with this one.