I didn't have any rattle noise issues with mine, but the wind noise was too high for my tastes, so I traded mine for their Double Bubble screen. I did like the hole in punched in the atmosphere, just didn't feel the extra noise was worth it. As I've said before though, windscreens effect different people in different ways. What's great for one may be terrible for someone else. The nice thing about ZG is they will give you 10 days to decide if you like a product or you can exchange it for another.