Well, if it's not yet time for a new chain, dropping 1T up front is cheaper than +3 in the rear because you don't have to buy a chain.
Reading posts over the years of folks with 14T, 15T & 16T countershaft sprockets, I'd have to say chain life has more to do with how well the chain was taken care of than if it's +/- 1 from stock. Any difference in "same owner" is likely to be small, and most will be willing to sacrifice 1-2K miles of chain life (if it's even that much) for the gearing they want.
Manny, how much of an improvement did you get out of an aluminum sprocket over the same tooth count in steel? I can understand it for the racer or the bling factor, but can you really feel a difference on an everyday bike?