According to the University of Minnisota, loud pipes don't save lives.
In fact a car will only hear your bike once you have passed them. In their study, loud pipes gave a rider no safety advantage what so ever.
As a licensed rider of 33 years with no car collisions under my belt, the advise I give to new riders is to ride like you are invisible, and that every cage on the road want's to kill you. The only way you will survive is to anticipate a cars next move, and never, ever ride in a position where if a cage makes a sudden lane change, he/she will hit you.
Hey it's worked for me so far!
I was unable to locate the origional U of M study, but here is an article written by an RCMP constable that pretty much confirms the U of M study.
LOUD PIPES DON'T SAVE LIVES,
TRAINED RIDERS DO!
I wrote an article on the above subject that generated some controversy. I posted it on the RCMP media website and it went country wide. It ended up in many newspepers and on several motorcycle discussion group bulletin boards and the rersponses there were interesting, to say the least. The "loudest" detractors were the riders who obviously had them installed on their bikes.
Testosterone or personal pride had blinded them to admitting that they were in no way a safety product, but simply another way of shouting "look at me". The whole subject was raised at the BC/AB rally in August when the Province newspaper carried a story about a Police crackdown on illegal systems, in response to numerous public complaints. It also carried pictures and quotes from a couple of the unapologetic riders who swore they would never remove the loud & illegal systems. Read on.
Start SEEING Motorcycles!!
"Police Crackdown on loud motorcycles" read the headlines. The stories that followed covered Police responses to public complaints about loud and illegal exhaust systems on motorcycles in different areas across B.C. It also documented responses from motorcycle riders who operated bikes with the systems that annoyed others. The riders of these loud machines touted the “loud pipes save lives” myth as their explanation for breaking the laws and annoying the public. As an experienced Member of the RCMP Vancouver Island Traffic Services, Police Motorcycle Operator, a Licenced Driving Instructor, A Senior Instructor of the RCMP Police Motorcycle Course, The Assistant National Director of Rider Education for the Gold Wing Road Riders Assn and a recreational and competition rider for 43 years, I have some insight to offer on this subject.
Analysis of thousands of motorcycle crashes, including the "Hurt Report" and our own ICBC data continues to show the recurring factors that cause car vs motorcycle crashes. The major cause is "the driver of the other vehicle violates the motorcyclists right of way". They do this by "making a left turn in front of the oncoming motorcycle". "More than 3/4ths of all accident hazards are within 45 degrees of either side of straight ahead". "The driver of the other vehicle did not SEE the motorcycle".
Another fact that these reports show is that 92% of the riders had no "professional" rider training experience. The ICBC books "RoadSense for Riders and Tuning Up for Riders" discuss a process called "hazard perception" and suggest riders "see-think-do" (it has also been called "SIPDE"). It involves a process where the rider actively scans the road ahead looking for anything that could cause problems, recognizes the problem, plans a way around it and leaves themselves an "out" if needed. Take a course and give yourself all the options you can get when you ride.
A safe, trained rider realizing that dark clothing and helmets makes them blend into other traffic, wears brighter colours. Why not install a headlight modulator and replace your "RoadRunner meep meep" horn with a louder air horn? Don’t replace your turn signals and brake lights with aftermarket ones that are hard to see and expect car drivers to see them. Use hand signals in addition to the signals so that your turning and braking is really obvious. All that removing the legal exhaust system from a motorcycle does is annoy others. The single biggest complaint Police get about bikes is for noise. A system that is facing to the rear of a machine will have no effect on alerting the oncoming traffic that is "within 45 degrees of straight ahead" but a headlight modulator, a set of air horns and bright clothing can. As a matter of note, only 1.2% of motorcycles were hit from behind while stopped.- the direction the pipes are pointing. If a vehicle is encroaching into your lane, move away and give them a blast of horn instead. If you are only relying on loud pipes pointing to the rear to save you, you have thrown away all the most effective tools.
The motorcycle awareness bumper sticker says it all...”Start SEEING Motorcycles”. I have never heard of any crash where the driver of the offending car said .."but Constable I didn’t HEAR the motorcycle".
Dave Hay, Cst.
Vancouver Island Traffic Services (South)
9921 Chemainus Rd.
Chemainus, B.C. V0R 1K1
Phone: (250) 416-0352
Fax: (250) 416 0354
Email: Dave.Hay@rcmp-grc.ca.ca
I would be interested in your point of view on this subject and would be happy to post it here next month. Drop me a line.
The origional article can be found here....
http://www.vwh.ca/rider-ed-canada/news.html