The first one is better, but far. To me anyway.
The second one would have been better if the sun wasn't 'melting' into the tank - say if it would have been over the seat instead.
I tend to actually like pics where you get lens refractions (or whatever the term is) in the pic, but I like the old-fashioned hex shapes, so the orange football doesn't do it for me.
I'm not even a good ametuer, just enjoy taking snapshots and sometimes I get lucky and come up with some I like. One of my fav's is this silhoutte shot near dusk of my friend, Matt:
This one winter sunset wouldn't have been too bad - if I would have just turned off the freakin' date stamp!