"...you might as well throw the shock away. " -- Interesting. Both the seller of the shock and my local mechanic said to use brake fluid in it, also the shop that did the charge said that was fine.
Seems I got bad advice and will now need to part with more $$$ to get it cleaned out and re-recharged. Dang.
Update: Took it to a suspension shop to open up, flush out, check seals, etc. If will rebuild ok, great, if not then I'll toss it.