The issue seems to be that the mounting bracket is thicker than the rubber washer/grommet Givi supplied. Since the bracket fits between the frame and the grab rail, the grab rail now sits the thickness of the bracket further from the fairing than it did before. The extra washer/grommet, in my case, doesn't fill up the gap between fairing and grab handle. Purely cosmetic and everything was stable but there was enough of a gap that the two washers would spin if touched and since it was two pieces stacked they could each spin differently. That weird shape of the washers made it really look funny.
My solution was to go to the hardware store and buy another set of rubber washers, trip them down to meet flush with the other washers (the weird rounded triangle shape). I now have three stacked rubber washers instead of two and everything looks good (Stock + Givi + Mine).